I graded them too soon. I've given it some more thought, and:
1. The superdeformed ones. Because it's so cute.
2. Yours. Because of Guardian content.
3. Florence's. Because, awesome!
4. The Wolverine. Well-drawn, but boring.
5. Gt-Sized. It's been done, and better.

I decided to vote with my own tastes rather than judging skill, because I'm sick of people making (comics) I don't like because somebody somewhere says 'that's what good stuff is', rather than caring about what's enjoyable.

~ Le Messor
"Maturity is only a short break in adolescence."
~ Jules Feiffer