Take a Point Give A Point Game to determine Alpha Talk Favorite Flight Member

[Mekko Hotvle]

Aurora 19 points
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 22 points
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 21 points
Puck 25 points (+1)
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 22 points
Talisman 4 points (-1)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 20 points

[Yankee]

Heh - I think it's time that we Minus two points (on the same person), but can only add 1 point, because it's feeling very circular. So that way the decrease is greater.

Let's do that starting tommorrow.

[Yankee]

Let's do that starting tommorrow.

And yes I realize in agreeing with this im likely not going to achieve my goal of getting vindicator in the top 5.

[Bill P]

Aurora 19 points
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 23 points (+1)
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 21 points
Puck 25 points
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 22 points
Talisman 3 points (-1)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 20 point

[Tawmis]

And so begins the -2 to the same character, and +1 to a character...

Aurora 19 points
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 23 points
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 21 points
Puck 25 points
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 22 points (+1)
Talisman 1 point (-2, I don't want to, but I know someone's going to knock her out soon, so I might as well send her close to packing...)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 20 point

[Yankee]

Aurora 19 points
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 23 points
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 21 points
Puck 25 points
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 20 points( -2)
Talisman 1 point
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 21 points (+1)
Whoever knocks talisman out would they get to sue their extra minus point on some one else?

[Phil]

Aurora 19 points
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 23 points
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 21 points
Puck 25 points
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 20 points
Talisman 2 points (+1)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 19 points (-2)

[Yankee]

Now I am utterly confused with how Phil is voting IT makes no sense lol

[Phil]

It makes it a cleaner kill now.

[Mekko Hotvle]

Aurora 20 points (+1)
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 23 points
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 21 points
Puck 25 points
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 20 points
Talisman 2 points (-2) (I'll kill off my own)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 19 points

[Tawmis]

Snowbird 20 points( -2)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 21 points (+1)
Whoever knocks talisman out would they get to sue their extra minus point on some one else?

Son of a... I didn't knock on Vindicator because I knew you want her in the top five and you knock on Snowbird?

As for the extra point, I'd say no - because there's a few with uneven number. I say if someone is at 1 point and someone uses their negative, it should just still go to one character. BUT - it is YOUR game, so the rules should fall on you to decide!

[Yankee]

Son of a... I didn't knock on Vindicator because I knew you want her in the top five and you knock on Snowbird?

As for the extra point, I'd say no - because there's a few with uneven number. I say if someone is at 1 point and someone uses their negative, it should just still go to one character. BUT - it is YOUR game, so the rules should fall on you to decide!

To be fair Ithought that once talisman was out you were going to likely g after her (as you said you only voted against talisman of mercy) and I didn't want to be the one to knock out talisman until we figured out how odd number eliminations work. How about you tell me who you want to go after next (besides vindicator) and I'll help you get them out?

[Phil]

at the teamwork going on here!

[Bill P]

Aurora 20 points
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 24 points (+1)
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 19 points (-2)
Puck 25 points
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 20 points
Talisman 2 points (-2) (I'll kill off my own)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 19 points[/QUOTE]

[Yankee]

Aurora 20 points
Guardian (James MacDonald Hudson) 24 points (+1)
Marrina 13 points
Northstar 19 points (-2)
Puck 25 points
Sasquatch 23 points
Shaman 22 points
Snowbird 20 points
Talisman 2 points (-2) (I'll kill off my own)
Vindicator (Heather McNeil Hudson) 19 points

[/QUOTE]

nevermind, you just let Mekkos -2 in when you quoted his post. carry on