Take a Point Give A Point Game to determine Alpha Talk Favorite Flight Member

[Yankee]

Should we remove feedback then?i mean he hasn't had any points taken or subtracted so removing him now wouldn't screw up the votes.

[Phil]

Can the game not be a long-term thing?
Failing that can we halve it & take 5 points off everyone?
The recent posts is getting flooded pretty quickly as it is; I think 2 votes per day would be overkill.

[Yankee]

So far weve only had two people other than me vote, and only one of those has voted more than once. If more people (like at least three) joined than yes 2 votes per day would be overkill. I am not opposed to taking 5 points off everyone.

[Phil]

Whatever works best for everyone playing; my ideas were just possible suggestions.
This forum tends to have peaks and troughs and periods of silence, as it's a pretty niche site with a small audience.
Is there a rush to crown a winner?

[Yankee]

No there's no rush to crown a winner. But a games not fun with only two people playing. I'm thinking Il do what you suggested, just halve everybody's points, Leave the give and take system in place, and then just teach myself the value of patience lol

[Yankee]

Game Restart: New Rules

1. Each character starts off with five points( the forum I got this game originally from started with ten points each, but their game even with around ten people playing on a daily basis, took two months to finish and the thread was at least 45 pages long)
2. When you vote you add a point to the character of your choice, while also taking away a point from another character.
3. Each player can only vote once per day
4. Once a characters point level reaches zero, they are eliminated
5. Last character remaining wins.
6. I limited this to characters who actually made the main Flight/Alpha Flight/Omega Flight roster simply to keep the list down. Il leave this list below up for twenty four hours. If during that time frame some one feels that I've left a character out or that I'm including characters that you feel weren't actual Flight members, either post in this thread or feel free to private message me. When the 24 hours is up, I will add/eliminate characters based on the input, post the updated list, and the game will begin.

Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 5 points
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 5 points
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 5 points
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 5 points
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 5 points
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 5 points
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 5 points
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 poin

[Yankee]

All right no one private messaged me any changes so the initial list stays as is. I'll cast the first vote:

Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 4 points (-1)
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 5 points
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 5 points
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 5 points
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 5 points
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 6 points (+ 1)
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 5 points
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 poin

[rplass]

Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 4 points
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 5 points
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 5 points
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 4 points (-1)
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 5 points
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 6 points
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 6 points (+1)
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 points

[Yankee]

Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 3 points (-1)
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 5 points
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 5 points
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 4 points
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 5 points
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 7 points (+1)
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 6 points
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 points

[Le Messor]

Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 3 points
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 6 points (+1)
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 5 points
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 3 points (-1)
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 5 points
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 7 points (+1)
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 6 points
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 points

[Yankee]

Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 2 points (-1)
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 6 points
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 6 points (+1)
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 3 points
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 5 points
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 7 points
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 6 points
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 points

[Madison]

I'll play, but to be honest there are so many hated characters on this list that it's hard to pick.


Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 2 points
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 6 points
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 6 points
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 2 points (-1)
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 6 points (+1)
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 7 points
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 6 points
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 points

[Yankee]

I'll play, but to be honest there are so many hated characters on this list that it's hard to pick.

Just curious how many characters on this list do you actively hate? There's many im indifferent towards, but I like way more on the list than I despise. And I know this will be controversial but I actually like the character of Michael Pointer. I don't like that Alpha flight died at his hands, I especially hate how rushed and disrespectful it was in how Bendis killed them, but I don't pin any of that on Michael Pointer. Despite the fact it was alpha flight ( or maybe because it was)m that moment where iron man and company remove the collective from Pointer, and Pointer all of a sudden is hit with the images of Alpha Flights death, the immense guilt he feels, over something he was just as much a victim in, that brought out the water works. Now bare in mind I hate the fact he was ever in Omega flight, particularly as the new guardian, but I hate that because of all the stupidly in that decision, not from any hatred of Michael (although I can completely understand and sympathize with Talisman's reaction when she sees him in the guardian suit.)

[Le Messor]

For me, him being in the Flight is enough. They weren't even given a choice.
Also, I'm personally going after Omega first, since to me they're not Alphans - especially US Agent, who has a foreign (to Canada) country in HIS NAME! But that's just me.

Aurora 5 points
Beta Ray Bill 5 points
Centennial 5 points
Diamond Lil 5 points
Earth Mover 5 points
Flex 5 points
Ghost Girl 2 points
Goblyn 5 points
Groundhog 5 points
Guardian 7 points (+1)
Madison Jeffries (AKA Box 2) 5 points
Major Mapleleaf 6 points
Manbot 5 points
Marrina 5 points
Michael Pointer 1 point (-1)
Murmur 5 points
Nemesis (Amelia Weatherly) 5 points
Northstar 6 points
Pathway 5 points
Persuasion 5 points
Puck 7 points
Puck (Zuzha Yu) 6 points
Radius 5 points
Roger Bochs (aka Box 1) 5 points
Sasquatch 5 points
Shaman 5 points
Smart Alec 5 points
Snowbird 5 points
Spider Woman (Julia Carpenter) 5 points
St. Elmo 5 points
Stitch 5 points
Talisman 5 points
U.S.Agent 5 points
Vindicator 5 points
Wild Child 5 points
Windshear 5 points
Yukon Jack 5 points

[Yankee]

Oh I completely agree. I not entirely opposed to having an American in Alpha Flight ( I mean I was born and raised in the U.S. So maybe I'm biased lol) but there are so many things wrong with Omega flight namely having the American government via shield deciding whose In Canada's team instead of the government of ya know Canada! they pick all-Americans including one who just happened to have inadverntly caused the death of the previous Flight, and Another in US agent who is somehow allowed to call himself a hero. When I put this list together I was tempted to to replace the Omegas in Beta Ray, Us Agent, and Pointer with Manikin, Witchfire, and Wyre, but for whatever reason I didn't do it.